FORCE POINTS!!!

HomeForumsGeneral ForumsSite FeedbackFORCE POINTS!!!

This topic has 1 voice, contains 30 replies, and was last updated by Avatar of X X 4185 days ago.

Viewing 15 posts - 16 through 30 (of 31 total)
Author Posts
Author Posts
June 11, 2003 at 4:04 pm #4895
Avatar of RevMen
RevMen

That’s a very good suggestion, Bob, and at first I was nearly convinced. However, while I can see how this idea would work well in a forum dedicated to its members helping each other out, I don’t feel like it would be as effective here. Some of our very best posts come from people with relatively low post counts. Think of supernerd23, he hardly ever posts around here, but when he does he sits down and really writes something worth reading.

I understand that the system avoids rewarding a high post count, and instead rewards a high useful post count, but Greg’s score would still get swalled up by someone who writes a lot of pretty good posts. For instance, Bob Page’s first post in this topic is definitely token-worthy. He brought in a good idea. But is it more valuable than one of Greg’s full-size posts? Probably not, but Greg’s might end up with only a few more tokens than Bob’s. Well, Bob writes a lot of posts that are of some value, and his score would eventually make Greg’s look pitiful.

I think the system is too simple in its definition of what a good post is, and that any system complicated enough to discern between a valuable post and a really valuable post would be too complicated for me to want to install here.

“Yolegoman” wrote: I think that Wierdears and Banjo and Jacopo should just be labaled “Forum Trolls” under their avitar and go from there.

Actually, Weirdears’s satirical trolling is some of the funniest material on this board. Also, it’s possible for some members to float in and out of troll-hood, always dancing around that line, and labeling them as a troll wouldn’t be completely fair. Perhaps we should just put “Spammer” under Yolegoman’s avatar, since his post count is 140 higher than the next closest member. :wink

June 11, 2003 at 4:35 pm #4900
Avatar of Yolegoman
Yolegoman

;)

Me? Spammer? :o

*Considers deleting username and starting over*

:lol:

I am so embarrased lol :oops:

I’ve been trying to cut down on my posts, looks like I need to double the diet hehe

I’ve got 421 posts! LOL!

And a average of about 6 posts a day… thats not so bad.

June 11, 2003 at 7:15 pm #4924
Avatar of Drunken Farmer Ben
Drunken Farmer Ben

I was going to try to respond to most everyone, but Ill just plain out say that it would not work out here… :)

June 12, 2003 at 2:07 am #4978
Avatar of Banjo
Banjo

It would work… Make a script for film ratings, and use that in the Post/Review forum! :)

That way people can rate a film, as well as give comments…

June 12, 2003 at 3:14 am #4983
Avatar of Drunken Farmer Ben
Drunken Farmer Ben

I didnt mean not work as in it couldnt be done, but not work in theory working into the community.

And kinda OT, but forum related. Isnt there a limitation to avatar sizes? It may have been when we moved over, but Ive noticed some peoples are larger

June 12, 2003 at 3:40 am #4985
Avatar of RevMen
RevMen

Yeah, for some reason when we moved forums everyone who had linked to a larger picture got a big avatar. The settings in the administration panel are still the same, but it seems those settings merely prevent people from adding pics that are too large, not continuing to check whether they are in compliance.

I’ve been just deleting pics out of people’s profiles that are obnoxiously large and then notifying them by PM. I think maybe I’ll just start deleting them without notification now.

June 12, 2003 at 7:36 am #5005
Avatar of T
T

“Bob Page” wrote: Please, force points would be awesome :)

example : http://www.csb-digital.com/alamdv/commu … /index.php

The owner of the forum (Revmen) give tokens to people who posts on the forum. Every token worth ten points (only when you give it!) if you keep it, it worths nothing. So when a member who have tokens see a post that answer is question or see a funny post, he can give a token to the post so the writter receive +10 points

The more points, the more helpful you are, and the more respect you have :D

P.S it will also be cool to make a points transfer system, like when I don’t have any token left, I can transfer 1 (or more…) point to someone

Thanks!

This whole post is one big joke.
No points, no token and none of the other user rating. Just grab your cam and do something.

sorry for being such a jerk.

June 12, 2003 at 12:34 pm #5022
Avatar of RevMen
RevMen

T, there’s nothing wrong anyone making suggestions, whether they seem like a good idea or not. It’s the whole point of the Site Redesign forum. If you don’t think a suggestion is a good idea, all you have to do is say you don’t think it’s a good idea, and hopefully you’ll give some reasons why you feel that way.

June 12, 2003 at 1:06 pm #5024
Avatar of T
T

Sorry….. :oops:

June 12, 2003 at 3:17 pm #5035
Avatar of mdn
mdn

mmmh…

I thought about this idea for a while and I am not sure such kind of systems are *so* useful.

About the film rating: We already have a rating system, that’s made by the comments every member is free to submit.
Adding a 1-5 (or whatelse) rating system, we will add just a graphical aspect to a feeling: the appreciation of the movie itself.

IMHO, this brings an advantage (seeing quickly what is the everage opinion about the film), but folows a major disadvantage, discouraging people, but the film’s author, to read comments.
Tipically I would expect a user going to the post and reviews directory, looking at the actual rating and choosing to download it or don’t.

It’s not my case (I download everything… :P ), but I think could be more interesting to leave people making their opinion about the worth if a film by reading comments and suggestions.

About the respect a member can gain, do you really need a glittering medal to show around?

I think respect is something coming from actions, not from a string below your avatar.

i.e.: When I started lurking around this forum, Bluntman had published his “Freaks” saga from not so a long time. I found it a bit racist (especially the episode where a peacefull hairy freak – Hagrid’s mini – got kicked) and not so humoristic as supposed. At the sametime, a flame war with a member called Dark Jedi, and different other re-incarnations after banning, was the *leit-motiv* of the forum (90% of the post made by lot of people at that time were, IMO, against the Forum Rules).
My final opinion about Bluntman was definitely not positive.

Then Bluntman’s efforts to be helpful and useful to the community, became more and more evident to me. Sure, my change of mind was helped by very funny movies (I liked a lot some of the serie “seven movies in seven days”), but what he did were the real base for the my growing respect.
I still don’t like some of his movies; I still do not like (maybe “understand” is a better word) his policy/jealousy about the characters he created, but for sure he has my respect for the efforts he made so far.

Hope this will explain my opinion and that you consider the main point
[selfQuote]
I think could be more interesting to leave people making their opinion about the worth if a film by reading comments and suggestions.
[/selfQuote]

as a costructive thumb-down.

Marco

June 12, 2003 at 10:32 pm #5086
Avatar of X
X

the points could work towards the chat also…..
if given enough points…..
one would gain the ability to use the chat…….
and access other “token”
abilitys……

another strange suggestion

June 12, 2003 at 10:34 pm #5088
Avatar of Bob Page
Bob Page

cool! cannot wait for this new points system :D

June 12, 2003 at 10:37 pm #5089
Avatar of X
X

“RevMen” wrote: I’ve been just deleting pics out of people’s profiles that are obnoxiously large and then notifying them by PM. I think maybe I’ll just start deleting them without notification now.

i was one of those with a larger picture and that happened to me
i had tried to resize it but decided against it……
i just went ahead and dropped the agent from matrix avatar and went with the decepticon avatar…….

and i love it……
(last half deleted for certain reasons)

June 13, 2003 at 8:01 pm #5154
Avatar of Brian of Gep
Brian of Gep

No offense intended,
but if you’ve been on boards that long,
wouldn’t you have learned how to spell correctly, punctuate, use complete thoughts,
and not act like a twelve year old?

June 13, 2003 at 11:42 pm #5184
Avatar of Buxton
Buxton

Proteus is by no means unique. You’d be surprised (or not, I don’t know) how many people in big business can’t string a coherent written paragraph together.

On the subject of ratings/force points/midichlorians/whatever, I still don’t really understand the need for them. If you post sensibly and constructively, people will come to respect your opinions. Hands up if you need to see a points total to decide whether hali’s worth listening to.

Viewing 15 posts - 16 through 30 (of 31 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.