but the problem had been dealt with

How has it been dealt with? Are you going to update your original reviews?

You can change past reviews… You click ‘review film’ and update your previous review. MoFR should know that.

I’ll admit that they were “Shitty” in the beginning, but the problem had been dealt with and there was no need for that kind of language.

If this is what you’re saying to the review panel, what are you saying to the other people in PMs?

A lot worse have been said about you elsewhere (forums). My use of language is just the tip of the iceberg.

Yes, Tim, I have only reviewed one film, but that is not the only part of the job. I have rejected more films than I can count. The only reason I’ve only done one review is because other reviewers get to the films before I do, and with the boarderline ones I have trouble deciding. Take Steve vs The Giant Alien Potato. I wanted to accept that one, but I didn’t know if it was good enough for the directory. So I’m a perfectionist. It’s not my fault. Maybe I should just start going with my gut instinct, but what do I do if people start complaining about more sub-par films being accepted?

And as The Doctor already said, you did not hire him or I as Reviewers.

And as I have implied over and over again in this thread, a Minister should be more supportive of newer members, especially one who is going to be reviewing their films. I know I’d feel pretty bad if I worked hard on a film, submitted it and had it rejected with the message “It’s crap.”
I might not even want to animate again.

I say we should have a vote. If more people want Tim to stay, I’ll shut up. But if more people want him to go, I’ll be one of the people running for MoFR.

“The Doctor” wrote: I know about what people have said on Ilovebrickfilming.com, but they apologized. Ie: The “Iceberg” melted just leaving your tip.

not that site. another forum

Actually, as far as I know, no one has done that. But that’s practically what he did in the “Was your film rejected?” thread (which has since been editied).

I was one of the original members added by RevMen back in the day, the day we cleared out more than 100 films in the queue. I wrote some reviews, many of questionable quality. One day, my good buddy Tim opened a private chat with me.

Tim: Can I say something?
Me: Sure.
Tim: You suck at writing reviews.

I thought about it, read some reviews of mine, read some reviews of his, and concluded that he knew what he was talking about. I got better at writing reviews.

This incident occurred when Tim and I were equals, before he actually had any power over other reviewers or the quality of their reviews. Now that Tim is in charge, he is simply continuing to ensure that the directory is filled with good reviews and good movies.

And The Doctor, you suck at writing reviews.

“The Doctor, reviewing The New Neighbor” wrote: This is defiantly a film not to be missed and I look forward to seeing more films by this director, now to find a beer.

But it may not be that you are hilariously incompetent and have no concept of sentence structure, but that you drink on the job.

if I were you, i would have said ‘and as this brickfilm also says “I’m going to get a beer”, I am going to do so’ or something similar.