Proposal – Minister of Brickfilming Welfare

Home Forums Governmental Forums Citizens Proposal – Minister of Brickfilming Welfare

This topic contains 23 replies, has 1 voice, and was last updated by Profile photo of saulgoode saulgoode 7 years, 9 months ago.

Viewing 10 posts - 1 through 10 (of 24 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #297261 Reply
    Profile photo of richardfrost
    richardfrost
    Member

    I would like to suggest a new Ministry, which I think might go some way to addressing some of the issues some members have and which have partially come to light in recent threads.

    We have a Minister of Discussion, which, essentially, is a moderator for all the forums, involving most effort, I presume, in Community and LDF.

    I propose we have a Minister of Brickfilming Welfare (or something). This person would essentially moderate the Brickfilming Forums, doing the following…

    – welcoming new registrants to the site and pointing out the features, resources and FAQs
    – moderate the Brickfilming forums
    – creation and moderation of a new ‘Start Here’ brickfilming forum, especially for newbies
    – marshal help and advice for newbies, calling in experienced help where needed
    – creation and management of a mentoring scheme, where a new member, genuinely wanting to improve, could be paired with a willing, experienced filmer
    – provide/encourage feedback on lower quality films being ignored in the forums, or which have been rejected from the directory
    – work with the Minister of Film Contest to create contests for newer members which will encourage them to learn and improve, and which give them a real chance of winning. These might be judged on greatest improvement over previous film, original storyline etc.
    – work with the Ministers of [various resources] to ensure these are fully accessible to new members

    If this Ministry was created, I would nominate myself to stand. It is probably a lot more suitable to my nature than my current ministry. Other suitable candidates might be Dewfilms, Saulgoode (yay, o/o/o/) or any experienced brickfilmer who cares to stand.

    I believe this role, focussing on developing talent, is currently not covered in the existing cabinet roles.

    Edit History – 1 = typos, 2 = add ‘encourage’ to the feedback bullet point

    #297266 Reply
    Profile photo of Squash
    Squash
    Member

    If this is created (I think it is a great idea), I would run.

    #297268 Reply
    Profile photo of Anonymous
    Anonymous
    Member

    #297271 Reply
    Profile photo of Kyle
    Kyle
    Member

    Awesome idea.

    – Kyle

    #297272 Reply
    Profile photo of Nick Durron
    Nick Durron
    Member

    This is a really great idea. It appears to cover some of the things I would have thought the Minister of Discussion should have been responsible for, but I guess he’s not.

    #297273 Reply
    Profile photo of richardfrost
    richardfrost
    Member

    “Nick Durron” wrote: It appears to cover some of the things I would have thought the Minister of Discussion should have been responsible for, but I guess he’s not.

    I guess not too. And in the election forum…

    “RevMen” wrote: Minister of Discussion (currently Cometgreen) – In charge of the forums and the chat. Responsibilities include setting standards for proper forums behavior and overseeing all moderators.

    So it’s not explicitly the role of the Minister of Discussion to do the things I have suggested need doing.

    #297274 Reply
    Profile photo of Watson
    Watson
    Member

    My concern with this is that it might encourage people to slack off more in doing these things, figuring that the MoBW will take care of it. They might not do it consciously, but over time, complacency could set in.

    Also, it would seem to seriously diminish the point of the MoD — or am I misunderstanding? Would the MoD still oversee those forums?

    #297276 Reply
    Profile photo of Squash
    Squash
    Member

    Would the MoD still oversee those forums?

    Yes. If I understand correctly, this job would be to watch out, and help new people. Create contests to inspire them to increase their skills, and review their films, so they know what to fix.
    EDIT: So the MoD would still have the same responsibilities.

    #297277 Reply
    Profile photo of Nick Durron
    Nick Durron
    Member

    It has come to my attention that BertL would perhaps be a good candidate for this position. He is very nice to new members, and already does some of the things required.

    #297285 Reply

    I’m going to be controversial and oppose this idea for several reasons:

    • Firstly, it is currently the role of the minister of discussion to moderate all forums. Dividing the community into to two parts, brickfilming and non brickfilming, is bound to lead to more people with rose tinted nostalgia glasses wanting forums deleted and members who don’t spend as long in certain forums criticised. If you feel that the brickfilming forums are not being run to a high enough standard, then this is most likely an issue with the current minister and not the system. I personally see nothing wrong with the way they are run at the moment.

      Secondly, there are many times more new non active accounts than active ones. Attempting to marshal all new “members” would invariable lead to sending PM’s to inactive accounts and generally wasting time trying to contact people who arn’t there. I would make a guess and say that only one in ten new accounts registered are people who become active and contributing members of our community. Additionally, I would imagine that many new members would rather explore the entire community than be limited to one forum (for a set period or whatever you had in mind).

      Thirdly, I doubt that you will find many experienced brickfilmers willing to be paired with new aspiring members. As much as we would all like to help new members, real life commitments and other such things often get in the way of us finishing our own projects, yet alone helping out an apprentice.

      Finally, almost all of the work and tasks that your minister would be exclusively taking on are open to any existing member (whether in a position of authority or otherwise) to do themselves. We can all, and often do, all of the following anyway:

      – welcoming new registrants to the site and pointing out the features, resources and FAQs
      – Offer our expertise to new brickfilmers wanting to improve or point them in the direction of other experts in the field in question, or simply give them advice in the threads which new members often set up with such queries.
      – provide feedback on lower quality films being ignored in the forums, or which have been rejected from the directory
      – advise the Minister of Film Contest to create, or create of our own accord, contests for newer members which will encourage them to learn and improve, and which give them a real chance of winning. These might be judged on greatest improvement over previous film, original storyline etc.
      – advise the Ministers of [various resources] and help to ensure these are fully accessible to new members

      Giving all of these tasks to one member would cause people to become complacent, and not help out new members or answer questions because it is someone else job. It would be very ironic if this system actually ended up limiting the help new members get, but I see this as a real possibility.

      Additionally, other proposed plans (such as a new member forum, organised mentoring scheme etc) could be implemented without the need to create a new ministry by the minister of discussion.

    So, to conclude, I believe the proposed ministry to be unnecessary, as there are already various tools in place to allow the aforementioned infrastructure changes and general behaviour towards new members to take place.

Viewing 10 posts - 1 through 10 (of 24 total)
Reply To: Proposal – Minister of Brickfilming Welfare
Your information: