IDEA Results!

This topic contains 62 replies, has 1 voice, and was last updated by  MindGame 14 years, 11 months ago.

Viewing 10 posts - 11 through 20 (of 62 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #318339

    Night Owl
    Participant

    Congratulations to the winners!
    I’m sort of surprised that Reputation managed to have the highest story score and still not place, though.

    Watson, could we see the individual scores for the other films too? It would be interesting.

    #318345

    Josh Parris
    Participant

    Quicklinks to the Post and Reviews of the top five:

    1. Crown of Syracuse
    2. The Inventor
    3. Hypothetical Possibilities
    4. Infinity Squared
    5. Reputation

    #318346

    Night Owl
    Participant

    Why just the top five?

    #318348

    Josh Parris
    Participant

    “Night Owl” wrote: Why just the top five?

    I wanted the top story, and the top three, and that leaves one missing. Besides which, the scores started dropping pretty fast after the top five.

    #318352

    Anonymous

    No reward chat?

    Oh well, well done to all the winners and people who entered!

    -Aled

    #318364

    Anonymous

    #318369

    Matt Gillan
    Participant

    Congratulations, I was kinda bumed out not too get on higher on presentation though.

    I thought Nick Durron’s would win, Smeagol come second and Shale to come third.

    #318374

    Night Owl
    Participant

    I’m slightly surprised that Nick’s entry and Matt’s entry are so far apart in the ranking, seeing as both of them have excellent visuals, but lack in the story area.

    #318381

    Munzapoppa
    Participant

    Note: Unofficial Prize

    For winning the IDEA competition, Smeagol gets free use of the recently-created un-official idea emoticon.

    #318392

    Nick Durron
    Participant

    “Night Owl” wrote: I’m slightly surprised that Nick’s entry and Matt’s entry are so far apart in the ranking, seeing as both of them have excellent visuals, but lack in the story area.

    Well, there is some difference in visuals. The Inventor has more impressive effects and such than Greatness does, and the I think the story is different in perhaps a better way. It also has talking, albeit with weird voices, something Greatness lacked. This is my somewhat subjective opinion, of course. I find it hard to really look at my film objectively, given that I made it.

Viewing 10 posts - 11 through 20 (of 62 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.